I think any person in the school would agree to read genre fiction, the freedom to read what you want, over literary fiction any day of the week because it would engage more students into reading. That’s what genre fiction is, it’s the freedom to read what intrigues you. But I do get why we still have curriculums where classic literary novels are taught because it helps restore the organization of what these English classes are looking to accomplish. From a school stand point it is obvious that the curriculum of the major subjects is based upon standardized testing and check points, rather than the value of learning for relevant knowledge. If teachers taught genre fiction, and in turn allowed students to read novels that they are interested in with more freedom, then there would be no order in their objective. Now I’m not bashing all teachers and our school because a majority of the teachers understand their role in teaching us young adults the value of learning and do a good job at it, but of course there’s always going to be the teachers that do the complete opposite of that. I don’t believe the curriculum will ever change in terms of what books are being taught, I personally wish they would, but it probably would never happen because it would be too hard to contain the school’s mission of learning. I do respect why we read Great Gatsby, To Kill a Mocking Bird and Catcher in the Rye, because they are classic novels that provide great human value/ historical value. Those were the only three books that I enjoyed, so it is a little curved, but you get my point. “Tomorrow you will be able to choose any novel that has come out in 2011 and read through it with no note taking and no quizzes. Just enjoy the book, dive into the book and take as long as you want to read it. Enjoy it to the greatest extent.” We all wish our teachers would blurt that out one day in class but due to our school, that probably won’t happen.
Monday, January 30, 2012
Genre Fiction
I think any person in the school would agree to read genre fiction, the freedom to read what you want, over literary fiction any day of the week because it would engage more students into reading. That’s what genre fiction is, it’s the freedom to read what intrigues you. But I do get why we still have curriculums where classic literary novels are taught because it helps restore the organization of what these English classes are looking to accomplish. From a school stand point it is obvious that the curriculum of the major subjects is based upon standardized testing and check points, rather than the value of learning for relevant knowledge. If teachers taught genre fiction, and in turn allowed students to read novels that they are interested in with more freedom, then there would be no order in their objective. Now I’m not bashing all teachers and our school because a majority of the teachers understand their role in teaching us young adults the value of learning and do a good job at it, but of course there’s always going to be the teachers that do the complete opposite of that. I don’t believe the curriculum will ever change in terms of what books are being taught, I personally wish they would, but it probably would never happen because it would be too hard to contain the school’s mission of learning. I do respect why we read Great Gatsby, To Kill a Mocking Bird and Catcher in the Rye, because they are classic novels that provide great human value/ historical value. Those were the only three books that I enjoyed, so it is a little curved, but you get my point. “Tomorrow you will be able to choose any novel that has come out in 2011 and read through it with no note taking and no quizzes. Just enjoy the book, dive into the book and take as long as you want to read it. Enjoy it to the greatest extent.” We all wish our teachers would blurt that out one day in class but due to our school, that probably won’t happen.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I like what your saying about freedom to read what you wan instead of being forced to swallow 'great literature.'
ReplyDeleteI think there could eventually be change. Our society is built on change and what can make things better. But I definitly think that there is going to always be some contraversy to what we read.
ReplyDeleteI would agree with you James. It would be amazing if students were able to pick whatever books they wanted to read with no tests or quizzes but you know that someone would abuse the system and completely ruin the chances of students being able to read whatever you wanted. :(
ReplyDeleteI agree with James that the idea of the schools actually allowing us to read more genre fiction instead of literary fictions will probably never occur, but if it were to I believe more young adults would partake in English classes.
ReplyDeleteI like what you said about "classic literary novels trying to restore the organization of what English classes are trying to accomplish." I completely agree with that. You shared your opinion well...Maybe one day it will change!
ReplyDelete